Consul vs Sanebox: AI Email Execution vs Inbox Filtering

Quick Comparison

What Sanebox Does Well

Sanebox is an email filtering service that learns which emails matter and automatically sorts the rest. It's been around since 2011 and has earned a strong reputation for reliable inbox cleanup.

Sanebox's Core Strengths

Automatic Priority Filtering: Sanebox learns your priorities by analyzing email patterns (sender importance, your past behavior, engagement signals). Important emails stay in your inbox; everything else moves to SaneLater for batch processing later.

One-Click Unsubscribe (SaneBlackHole): Drag any email to SaneBlackHole, and you'll never hear from that sender again. Simpler than finding unsubscribe links.

Follow-Up Reminders: SaneReminders lets you set reminders for emails awaiting response. If you haven't heard back by a certain time, Sanebox notifies you.

Snooze Functionality: Temporarily archive emails to resurface at a better time.

Universal Compatibility: Works with any email provider—Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, Apple Mail, Exchange, any IMAP. No app to install; it works directly with your email server.

Privacy-Focused: Sanebox only analyzes email headers (sender, subject, timestamp), never message content. Your actual emails remain private. SOC 2 Type II certified.

Who Sanebox Works Best For

Sanebox excels for professionals who:

• Receive lots of low-priority email (newsletters, notifications, marketing)
• Want inbox noise reduced automatically
• Use multiple email providers
• Value privacy (no content scanning)
• Don't need AI drafting or execution

Where Sanebox Falls Short

Sanebox is a filtering tool. It helps you see what's important faster. It doesn't help you act on anything.

No Email Drafting

Sanebox can't write emails. When you need to respond to an important message that Sanebox surfaced, you're still writing it yourself. The time-consuming part of email isn't finding important messages—it's crafting responses.

No Scheduling Execution

When someone emails "Can we find 30 minutes next week?", Sanebox does nothing. You still need to:

1. Read the request
2. Open your calendar
3. Find available times
4. Draft a response with options
5. Wait for their reply
6. Handle counter-proposals
7. Confirm the meeting
8. Create the calendar event

That coordination process—7+ emails for one meeting—remains entirely manual.

No Voice Matching

Sanebox doesn't learn your writing style because it doesn't write anything. The "generic AI voice" problem doesn't apply, but neither does the solution.

No Follow-Up Execution

SaneReminders will notify you when you haven't heard back. But then what? You still need to write the follow-up, decide timing, craft appropriate language. Sanebox surfaces the need; you do the work.

Passive vs. Active

Sanebox is fundamentally passive. It reorganizes your inbox view. You still do all the email work—just with less noise. For professionals whose bottleneck is doing email, not finding email, Sanebox solves the wrong problem.

How Consul Is Different

Consul focuses on email execution—actually handling the work, not just organizing it.

Email Execution, Not Just Organization

When email arrives, Consul:

1. Triages immediately with priority labels
2. Drafts a reply if one is needed, written in your voice
3. Identifies scheduling requests and prepares availability-based responses
4. Waits for your approval before sending anything

You review the draft, approve (or edit), and it sends. The work is done—not just organized.

Full Scheduling Handling

When someone asks to meet, Consul:

1. Recognizes the scheduling request
2. Checks your real calendar availability
3. Considers your scheduling preferences (preferred times, buffer between meetings)
4. Drafts a response with 3-4 available slots
5. Waits for your approval
6. Sends when you confirm
7. Handles their reply and counter-proposals
8. Books the meeting when times align
9. Sends confirmation to all parties

You approve key steps; Consul handles the coordination. One meeting that would take 7+ manual emails becomes 2-3 approvals.

Voice Matching Through Analysis

Consul analyzes your past sent emails to learn your writing style. Auto-drafts sound like you wrote them—your vocabulary, your tone, your patterns. Recipients can't tell AI drafted it.

Sanebox doesn't write, so this comparison doesn't apply.

Follow-Up Tracking AND Execution

Consul tracks threads awaiting response. When follow-up is appropriate, Consul:

1. Identifies the right timing based on relationship and context
2. Drafts an appropriate follow-up message
3. Waits for your approval
4. Sends when you confirm

Sanebox reminds you to follow up. Consul drafts and sends the follow-up (with your approval).

Human-in-the-Loop Safety

Every external action requires your approval. You see exactly what will send before it sends. AI mistakes stay private—you catch them before recipients do.

This matters less for Sanebox because Sanebox never sends anything. But for tools that take action on your behalf, approval workflows are essential for professional communication.

Use Cases: Who Should Choose What

Choose Sanebox If You:

• Primarily need inbox noise reduction
• Receive many newsletters, notifications, and marketing emails
• Want filtering to work silently in the background
• Use multiple email providers that need unified filtering
• Value privacy (header-only analysis)
• Have a small budget for email tools
• Don't need AI drafting or execution

Typical Sanebox user: Marketing manager who receives 200+ emails daily, mostly notifications and newsletters, who needs to surface the 20 that matter.

Choose Consul If You:

• Spend significant time writing email responses
• Have scheduling requests that require coordination
• Need follow-ups tracked and executed
• Want replies drafted in your personal voice
• Require approval before anything sends
• Have relationship-focused work (clients, investors, partners)
• Value daily briefings covering email, calendar, and Slack

Typical Consul user: Consultant or founder who spends 2+ hours daily on email coordination and needs that time back without sacrificing communication quality.

Use Both If You:

Both tools solve different problems. Using them together:

• Sanebox reduces inbox noise so fewer emails reach your main view
• Consul handles execution on the important emails that remain
• Together: less noise + faster action on what matters

The tools don't conflict. Sanebox filters at the server level; Consul executes on what you see.

Pricing Comparison

Sanebox is significantly cheaper because it does less. Filtering requires minimal AI processing. Execution—drafting, voice matching, scheduling coordination—requires more sophisticated AI.

The comparison isn't apples-to-apples. Sanebox's $7/month saves you scanning time. Consul's $50/month ($25 founding) saves you writing, scheduling, and follow-up time. Calculate based on your hourly rate and time spent on each.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Inbox Organization

Sanebox: Automatically moves emails to folders (SaneLater, SaneNews, SaneBlackHole). Learns from your behavior over time. Works silently without app installation.

Consul: Labels emails in Gmail with priority tiers. Integrates with your existing label system. Provides triage context in daily briefing.

Winner: Sanebox for pure organization. Consul's labeling is useful but secondary to execution.

Email Drafting

Sanebox: No capability.

Consul: Auto-drafts replies in your voice based on analysis of your past emails. Drafts await approval before sending.

Winner: Consul (only option).

Scheduling

Sanebox: No capability.

Consul: Full scheduling execution—detects requests, checks calendar, drafts availability, handles back-and-forth, books meetings, sends confirmations. Dedicated inbox (CC your Consul) for delegated scheduling.

Winner: Consul (only option).

Follow-Up Management

Sanebox: SaneReminders sends notifications when emails you're tracking haven't received responses.

Consul: Tracks threads, calculates appropriate follow-up timing, drafts follow-up messages, sends with approval.

Winner: Consul for execution; Sanebox for simple reminders.

Privacy

Sanebox: Only analyzes headers (sender, subject, date). Never reads email content. Strong privacy positioning.

Consul: Reads full email content to understand context and draft appropriate responses. Content processed for AI but not used for model training.

Winner: Sanebox for privacy-first users. Consul requires content access to function.

Universal Email Support

Sanebox: Works with any IMAP provider—Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, Apple Mail, Exchange, and more.

Consul: Currently Gmail-focused with Outlook support coming soon.

Winner: Sanebox for multi-provider support.

Pricing

Sanebox: $3.49-12/month depending on features.

Consul: $50/month ($25 founding members).

Winner: Sanebox for budget. Consul for value if execution features are needed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use Sanebox and Consul together?

Yes, and they complement each other well. Sanebox filters your inbox at the server level, reducing noise. Consul then handles execution on the important emails that remain. Less noise + faster action = maximum efficiency.

Does Sanebox draft emails?

No. Sanebox focuses exclusively on filtering and organization. It moves emails between folders and provides reminders, but it never writes or sends anything on your behalf.

Does Consul filter my inbox?

Consul triages and labels emails, but it's not primarily a filtering tool. Its focus is execution—drafting replies, handling scheduling, tracking follow-ups. For aggressive noise filtering, Sanebox is more specialized.

Which is better for privacy?

Sanebox only reads email headers (sender, subject, timestamp), never content. Consul reads full email content to understand context and draft appropriate responses. If content privacy is paramount, Sanebox is more restrictive. If you need execution features, content access is necessary.

Is Sanebox cheaper than Consul?

Yes, significantly. Sanebox starts at $3.49/month; Consul is $50/month ($25 founding). But they solve different problems. Sanebox saves scanning time; Consul saves writing, scheduling, and coordination time. The relevant comparison is time saved × your hourly rate.

Which helps more with scheduling?

Consul, entirely. Sanebox has no scheduling features. Consul handles the complete scheduling workflow: detecting requests, checking availability, drafting responses, managing back-and-forth, booking meetings, and sending confirmations.

The Bottom Line

Sanebox is an inbox filter. It reduces noise by automatically sorting unimportant emails to folders. You still read, write, and send everything yourself—just with less clutter. It's affordable, privacy-focused, and works with any email provider.

Consul is an email execution assistant. It drafts replies in your voice, handles scheduling conversations end-to-end, and tracks follow-ups—all with your approval before anything external happens. It requires Gmail (Outlook coming) and costs more, but it does the work, not just organizes it.

If your problem is "too many emails to scan," Sanebox helps.

If your problem is "too much time writing emails, scheduling, and following up," Consul helps.

Many professionals have both problems. The tools work well together.

---

Try Consul

Ready to delegate email execution, not just filtering?

Create your assistant in minutes. No demos, no sales calls. Connect your Gmail, and Consul immediately starts triaging your inbox and drafting replies in your voice.

CC your Consul on scheduling emails to delegate coordination entirely. Review everything before it sends.

See what email execution feels like—without the risk.